Sweatpant Jeans Review: Rag & Bone vs GAP

It’s been a rainy (though very welcome!) start to the new year, which means I’ve been living in cozy outfits and spending more time indoors. My sweatpant “jeans” from two different brands have been in heavy rotation, so I figured it was finally time to give them a proper review.

Rag & Bone Sweatpant Jeans Review

In 2024, I caved and bought the infamous Rag & Bone sweatpant jeans, which retail for $198. They come in multiple washes, including a darker option that’s perfect for fall and winter.

For sizing reference: I typically wear a 26 or 27 in jeans. I purchased a size medium while pregnant and was able to wear them through most of my pregnancy. They still fit comfortably postpartum as well.

One confusing detail: the Miramar line actually includes two different constructions.

• Version 1: “Hard jeans” with a working fly and button, but made from soft terry fleece.
• Version 2: Labeled “decorative five-pocket style.” These are the true sweatpant version. The fly and button are printed on, and the functional pockets are hidden in the side seams.

If you look closely at the product photos, you can spot the difference. My review is on the second version, which is as close to sweatpants as you can get!

My Thoughts

• I love the detailed denim “print” — it looks surprisingly realistic.
• The silhouette is smoother and more streamlined, with slightly nicer construction overall.
• The elastic waistband runs looser, which can be a pro or a con.
• Con: I can’t put anything heavy (like my phone) in the side seam pocket or the pants start to sag.

GAP Sweatpant Jeans Review

More recently, GAP released their own version of sweatpant jeans in several styles: a heavyweight option, a trendy barrel style, and a lightweight direct dupe of the Rag & Bone pair.

I purchased the heavyweight version in an XS and have worn them for more than six months now. Here’s how they compare to the Rag & Bone version:

• Wider size range, including petite and tall options
• More fabric choices and weight variations
• The heavyweight style has real pockets and belt loops
• Costs about half as much as the Rag & Bone version – even less if you get it during a frequent GAP sale.

Are the Rag & Bone Sweatpant Jeans Worth It?

To be completely honest… probably not.

That said, when I checked my closet tracking app, I realized I’ve worn them over 60 times in the past year. At that point, the cost-per-wear comes out to just below $2 – which makes the higher price tag easier to justify.

If you have the budget and prefer the slightly more streamlined silhouette, the Rag & Bone version is great. If not, the GAP styles are extremely comfortable and deliver a very similar look for much less.

Partnership Disclosure: This blog post was not sponsored by any of the brands listed above. As always, all opinions are my own. This post may contain affiliate links, in which I earn a commission on purchases.